Format Mac Passport drive to use on Windows

Hello,

I would like to use this drive WD My Passport for Mac External Hard Drive HDD, USB-C and USB-A Compatible | Western Digital on Windows machines.
My question is: is there any risk to formatting this to work with Windows computers? Because it’s a Passport drive and it has the encryption, is there any chance that by formatting it to make it unsusable?
I am asking because I did try to format an older 512 GB My Book drive with encryption, and it became unrecognisable on Windows. Basically I am no longer able to use it, luckily I didn’t have any data on it.
Thank you!

The encryption/decryption is handled by a chip on the logic board.

Formatting the drive does not wipe/format the chip.

There should be no risk in formatting the drive with your file system of choice if you know what you are doing.

But, it doesn’t sound like you do

Well, most external hard drives are designed to work for Windows computers. Windows was mainly optimized for NTFS (New Technology file system) format, on the other hand, APFS was created for the Mac OS. NTFS is not compatible with Mac and similarly, APFS does not get along with Windows. So if you’re trying to connect an external hard drive to a Mac or Windows, you might have to format the drive before as per the system’s requirement.

Further, I suggest you to check the below link that explains all the methods to format your external drive without any data loss:

Hope it helps!

Yes, there is some risk. WD My Passport for Mac drives often come pre-formatted with APFS (Apple File System) or HFS+ (Hierarchical File System Plus, also called Mac OS Extended), which Windows cannot read natively. If the drive has WD Security/encryption enabled, formatting it on Windows will destroy the encrypted volume, making the data inaccessible.

For a safe approach:

  1. First, remove encryption using WD Security on a Mac.

  2. Then, format the WD drive to exFAT, which is compatible with both Mac and Windows. Alternatively, you can use third-party software to enable read/write support for the Mac-formatted drive if you prefer not to reformat it. ( How to Use a Mac-Formatted HFS+/APFS Hard Drive on Windows )

Since your WD My Passport drive has encryption enabled (likely Apple’s FileVault or WD’s own encryption), formatting the drive will typically remove this encryption. However, if the drive is encrypted with a proprietary or hardware-based encryption, there is a risk that formatting could render the drive unreadable or cause data loss, especially if the encryption is tied to specific hardware or software.